Is virtual currency illegal in India?
I'm reading about central bank's warning against virtual currencies like BitCoin. I couldn't find any mention about BitCoins being 'illegal in India'. My question is more generic - is virtual currency illegal in India? That is, if I buy 'credit points' for an online service in India using real money and then I redeem these credit points against the services I use on the site - am I doing anything illegal?
My understanding of virtual currency indicates that it's similar to buying a 'gift card' on Amazon.com for yourself and then using that gift-card for various purchases. This is allowed; but I just want to be 100% sure.
Anyone?
My understanding of virtual currency indicates that it's similar to buying a 'gift card' on Amazon.com for yourself and then using that gift-card for various purchases. This is allowed; but I just want to be 100% sure.
Anyone?
Replies
-
lovejeetI don't think it should be illegal. I have heard about airtel money, a concept which involved virtual transfer of money through the cell phones. So if Airtel can provide that service, i guess it wl be illegal.
-
Sanyam KhuranaGift cards cannot be considered illegal (Damn Sure)
You are just buying stuff, exchanging real money with gift cards as virtual currency.
But Bitcoins is something which I have doubt with, people join the pool, mine bitcoins, they are actually what can be (not must) illegal. -
Anand TamariyaBitcoin is not illegal - neither is its mining. RBI issued a warning just to ensure people who don't understand it don't lose money in it especially considering wide fluctuations it has seen in its valuation.
-
sauhardNah virtual currencies such as Bitcoin, payza pioneer and especially paypal are not illegal in india. However there are some restrictions of some currencies in india such as paypal that online buying of goods is not possible from paypal in india nowon. But there are some massive advantages of paypal.
I do work in online currencies and stuffs so if you need any help pm me -
Anand Tamariya
I'd like to know the advantages of paypal.sauhardBut there are some massive advantages of paypal.
I do work in online currencies and stuffs so if you need any help pm me -
Kaustubh Katdare@#-Link-Snipped-# - thank you for your response. My specific question is: There's a flash banner maker website that lets you create animated flash banners online. In order to use these banners; the website asks you to purchase 'virtual points'. For example, for $19.99; they will give you about 50 'virtual points'. These virtual points can be redeemed across their partner websites at any time you want. It's like 'topping up' your account and then consuming your digital points to make various 'purchases' on their partner websites. The system is beautifully designed.
I was concerned whether buying virtual points would be illegal in India. I think it's not; but just making sure that it's a fact. -
Sanyam Khurana
BITCOIN is illegal now in India.sauhardNah virtual currencies such as Bitcoin, payza pioneer and especially paypal are not illegal in india. However there are some restrictions of some currencies in india such as paypal that online buying of goods is not possible from paypal in india nowon. But there are some massive advantages of paypal.
I do work in online currencies and stuffs so if you need any help pm me
RBI banned trading of Bitcoins.
Now they can put you in jail.
Final jurisdiction has come. -
sauhard
Sorry bit too late in replying. But yeah that virtual currency is not illegal.Kaustubh Katdare@#-Link-Snipped-# - thank you for your response. My specific question is: There's a flash banner maker website that lets you create animated flash banners online. In order to use these banners; the website asks you to purchase 'virtual points'. For example, for $19.99; they will give you about 50 'virtual points'. These virtual points can be redeemed across their partner websites at any time you want. It's like 'topping up' your account and then consuming your digital points to make various 'purchases' on their partner websites. The system is beautifully designed.
I was concerned whether buying virtual points would be illegal in India. I think it's not; but just making sure that it's a fact.
Consider freecharge.in as an exmaple. They also offer virtual currency points known as -"CREDITS". Also take the example of a major online shop- jabong.com also stores currency in virtual points.
Ebay also offers vrtual currency which can redeemed on various sites. So i am pretty sure it's not illegal.
THe illegal part comes when you either store a large amount of money online outside india in various virtual currencies (Well's that's new trend now 😛) -
sauhard
Still kindda confused but check this:Sanyam KhuranaBITCOIN is illegal now in India.
RBI banned trading of Bitcoins.
Now they can put you in jail.
Final jurisdiction has come.
Bitcoins per se are not illegal in India: Nishith Desai - The Hindu -
Kaustubh KatdareI think it will never be illegal. The netbanking thing is all virtual and no 'real' money is transferred between the banks.
-
sauhard
yup But there is still a limit on netbanking transactions 😔😡Kaustubh KatdareI think it will never be illegal. The netbanking thing is all virtual and no 'real' money is transferred between the banks. -
ISHAN TOPRE
Buying a bitcoin is risky. You buy a bitcoin from say INR 10000 and then lose interest which you would have otherwise earned from bank term deposit.Kaustubh KatdareI think it will never be illegal. The netbanking thing is all virtual and no 'real' money is transferred between the banks.
Also, as there is no regulation, you cannot predict what will become of the value of Bitcoin. Today it is highest rated so called currency. Tomorrow it may be zero.
The same is not a case with rupee, dollar, yen, yuan etc. These are tradable commodities and their appreciation and depreciation has a logic unlike Bitcoin.
However in my opinion, getting a bitcoin is not illegal. You correctly said as it is synonymous to buying a gift card. The Reserve Bank of India has only issued a warning to trade carefully in the unregulated money market. The matter is under review. You may like to read this- #-Link-Snipped-#
P.S: Do not refer to RBI as Central bank, it may be confused with central bank of India (In your founding post).
Central bank of India is only a consumer bank. Reserve bank of India is a regulatory bank.
You are reading an archived discussion.
Related Posts
How many of you are regular visitor of CrazyEngineers Fan Page?
If you have not been there for a while, I would suggest you to bookmark the page, as we...
BenQ, the top global brand in projectors, has launched its new series of ultra bright projectors in India today. These 4 new projectors are equipped with the SmartEco technology and...
How many of you are on [HASHTAG]#facebook[/HASHTAG] , [HASHTAG]#Google[/HASHTAG] plus , [HASHTAG]#twitter[/HASHTAG] ?
And how many of you believe that along with entertainment social media apps can be utilized as...
What does the numbers 9000, 14000 and other such things denote in ISO?
Why they are named so?
I have a year gap in Engg. am i ELIGIBLE?
I have 700 something people above me in DAC can any1 suggest some good centres in MUMBAI n PUNE ?