Which company offers the best external hard disk?

@sanyam-Nl7Zqc • Oct 19, 2024

Oct 19, 2024

1.3K

Hey CEans,

I was thinking to get an External Hard Disk of 1 TB.
Should I buy hard disk from Seagate ,or any other company?

If anyone, has used it (any companies' hard disk), please post your review.

Thanks.

Like 0 Replies 14

Replies

Welcome, guest

Join CrazyEngineers to reply, ask questions, and participate in conversations.

CrazyEngineers powered by Jatra Community Platform

lovebox

@lovebox-ZyXFqj • Sep 14, 2013

I think Seagate is good. But if you want to go for something rugged, try the Transcend Storejet. Its a little more expensive than Seagate but it is drop tested and also features the one touch auto back-up button.
0
Sanyam Khurana

@sanyam-Nl7Zqc • Sep 15, 2013

lovebox
I think Seagate is good. But if you want to go for something rugged, try the Transcend Storejet. Its a little more expensive than Seagate but it is drop tested and also features the one touch auto back-up button.
Thanks for the reply, and do you have any idea about Maxtor, and Western Digital?
0
Sarathkumar Chandrasekaran

@sarathkumar-FEGRPw • Sep 15, 2013

I still insist you to go for Seagate. My friends had given a good review on it.The reliability of Seagate is quite good.Sorry , I dont have any ideas on western digital and maxtor.
0
Jeffrey Arulraj

@jeffrey-xA7lUP • Sep 16, 2013

I heard about Sony's 1TB hard drive They are cooler than the others But no idea about the variation in their performance

Just make sure that the hard drive is suiting your USB port in built in your system
0
[Prototype]

@prototype-G9Gn5k • Oct 1, 2013

Go for Western Digital. You won't be disappointed.
0
Saandeep Sreerambatla

@saandeep-sreerambatla-hWHU1M • Oct 2, 2013

I have been using Western Digital since 2.5 years and it works very well.

I have almost 80% of the disk filled with data and movies.

I connect it to my telivision and my laptop daily and use it daily. So till now there are no problems faced.

The only drawback is the connecting chord's length.
0
Nayan Goenka

@nayan-Dhpt4N • Oct 4, 2013

I own 2 external HDDs. Both seagate. One is 640Gb other is 1Tb. And I am satisfied with the performance. You can opt for Seagate. I couldn't comment on other brands since I didn't use them.
0
Sanyam Khurana

@sanyam-Nl7Zqc • Oct 4, 2013

Ok, Now I'm thinking to get one of either Seagate or Western Digital, many people have given me positive reviews about both of them, not only here, but on other forums too..
0
Abhishek Rawal

@abhishek-fg9tRh • Oct 4, 2013

Western Digital & Seagate both are equally good. But as I own Western Digital & it's working fine from last one year, I will vote for WD.
0
Jeffrey Arulraj

@jeffrey-xA7lUP • Oct 5, 2013

A Hard disk works fine for 8 to 10 years after that it will show its true colour

If you are planning one for such a long use make a wise decision otherwise both the companies have the best product as of now
0
Anoop Mathew

@anoop-FRTf1L • Dec 27, 2014

-1 for Seagate 👎

I've been using a Seagate BackUp Plus 1 TB for about 2 years now. From last week onwards, my windows explorer keeps crashing while I'm accessing files, and it gets undetected while watching videos. Formatted it twice with regular Windows format and recopied some files from my Laptop to the HDD. Sadly, the same thing keeps happening while playing videos or accessing files. I'm a rough user and I can say that it doesn't take a beating that well.

Looking forward to getting a WD Essentials My Passport Ultra or a Transcend Storejet.

People in most forums keep advising to take a 'back-up' of your "back-up" if the data is that valuable to you. You never know which HDD can ruin your day, and when!😡
0
Abhishek Rawal

@abhishek-fg9tRh • Dec 27, 2014

#-Link-Snipped-# Sometimes Filesystems are culprit and not everytime HDD. Since you're using Windows or OS X you don't have any choice other than NTFS or HFS respectively.

You never know what could be the problem. I was using BtrFS (Better FS) and sometimes my plasma used to crash, however after much research in BtrFS I found that any software using preallocated files & mmap() on it, it crashes. Sadly have to go back to Ext4.

In short what I mean is, you might've encountered an NTFS bug.

0
Anoop Mathew

@anoop-FRTf1L • Jan 10, 2015

Abhishek Rawal
#-Link-Snipped-# Sometimes Filesystems are culprit and not everytime HDD. Since you're using Windows or OS X you don't have any choice other than NTFS or HFS respectively.

You never know what could be the problem. I was using BtrFS (Better FS) and sometimes my plasma used to crash, however after much research in BtrFS I found that any software using preallocated files & mmap() on it, it crashes. Sadly have to go back to Ext4.

In short what I mean is, you might've encountered an NTFS bug.
Guys, a quick update. Tried wiping the entire HDD and resetting the whole thing. The data gets copied alright, but while accessing it's a pain in the ass as almost half of the time it doesn't work (as in either the data is half corrupt/inaccessible/parts of it are accessible at 'particular' times). So after about 2 weeks of trials I was really annoyed today, and I just took it down with a Hammer!!

Guess what:- Found Samsung's Stuff inside Seagate HDD!!😨

P.S.: Already there was a lot of rough use and falls during usage, so I didn't bother to go with warranties/further-repairs. Took a video of the Killing too...!

0
Anoop Mathew

@anoop-FRTf1L • Jan 10, 2015

Anoop Mathew
Guess what:- Found Samsung's Stuff inside Seagate HDD!!😨

Looks like they do this. More Info #-Link-Snipped-#. 😨But why? Is it another reason for degradation so early? Normally original 'Seagate' HDD last a lot better. 😳

0