Are Mechanical Keyboard Keys Harder to Press?

By - Kaustubh Katdare • 11 months ago • 31.1k views

I'm considering switching to a mechanical keyboard like NuPhy Air 75 or 96, but wondering if the keys are harder to press.

Been watching a lot of videos on YouTube about how easy and comfortable it is to type on a Mechanical Keyboard.

I'm currently used to typing on Apple Magic Keyboard. If anyone of you have made a switch from Apple Magic Keyboard to Mechanical Keyboard, please let me know your experience. Thank you!

Replies

  • Steve
    Steve Gracia

    Switched from Apple Magic Keyboard to Mechanical Keyboard - Keychron Q6 about 3 months ago. Never been happier.

    I'd be more than happy to shed some light on your questions about mechanical keyboards and how they compare to the Apple Magic Keyboard.

    To answer your first question, whether the keys on mechanical keyboards are harder to press, it's essential to understand that there are various types of mechanical switches that vary in actuation force (the amount of force required to activate the key).

    Here's a brief rundown of the most common mechanical switch types:

    Linear switches (e.g., Cherry MX Red, Gateron Red):

    These have a smooth, consistent keystroke with no tactile bump or audible click. I went to the store to check and was thoroughly impressed.

    The actuation force required for these switches is typically around 45g, making them relatively light to press.

    Tactile switches (e.g., Cherry MX Brown, Gateron Brown):

    These switches have a tactile bump when the key is actuated, providing a slight feedback to the typist.

    They generally have a similar actuation force to linear switches, around 45g-55g.

    Clicky switches (e.g., Cherry MX Blue, Gateron Blue): These switches have both a tactile bump and an audible click upon actuation, making them more "noisy" than other types. The actuation force varies but is typically around 50g-60g.

    Compared to the Apple Magic Keyboard, which uses scissor-switch technology, mechanical keyboards may feel harder or easier to press depending on the specific switch type.

    Scissor-switch keyboards require an actuation force of around 45g-55g and have a lower key travel distance.

    So, in general, mechanical keyboards with linear or tactile switches should have a similar actuation force to the Apple Magic Keyboard, while clicky switches might require slightly more force.

    As for typing experience, this is highly subjective and depends on personal preferences.

    Some people prefer the tactile feedback and longer key travel distance of mechanical keyboards, which can lead to increased typing speed and accuracy for some users.

    In contrast, others prefer the low-profile and quiet nature of the Apple Magic Keyboard. A mechanical keyboard may be better suited for long typing sessions, gaming, or if you enjoy a more audible and tactile typing experience.

    The Apple Magic Keyboard, on the other hand, is more portable, sleek, and provides a more subtle typing experience.

    To conclude, whether the keys on mechanical keyboards are harder to press depends on the switch type and how it compares to the scissor-switch mechanism of the Apple Magic Keyboard.

    As for the typing experience, it's largely subjective and comes down to personal preference.

    I'd recommend trying out a few different mechanical keyboards with various switch types to find the one that suits your typing style and preferences best.

    Happy typing!

  • Bruce
    Bruce Wathan

    The typing experience on Apple keyboard is much better than the mechanical keyboard. I'd highly recommend actually using a mechanical keyboard before you consider switching.

    The travel on the Magic Keyboard is minimal; which makes it easier to type on. But if you really want the click-click-click sound when you type (which I find very irritating), go for a mechanical keyboard.

Note: Only logged-in members of CrazyEngineers can add replies.

Other questions

Can an engineer become a doctor? If you got forced into studying engineering and want to go back to your first love - medicine (MBBS), what are your options? Let's discuss.

Yes, an engineer can become a doctor. But it won't be easy. Engineering degrees worldwide are mostly 4-year degree courses and medicine too requires an average of 4-5 years followed by mandatory internship. Not everyone has the patience, money and time to dedicate a decade only to learning.

If you are an engineer or engineering student who wants to...

I was recently asked if a data engineer can become a data science. How difficult is it for data engineers to switch career to data scientist and what type of training is involved. Looking for responses from data engineers and data scientists.

A data engineer can become a machine learning engineer with proper training. Keep in mind that being a data engineer is not a prerequisite for becoming a machine learning engineer.

I find this question very similar to Can data engineer become a data scientist?. Do take a look at that discussion as well.

Data engineering is an emerging field in the big-data domain and there's a growing demand for data engineers.

A typical data engineer role involves collecting data, creating data pipelines, verifying the data, correcting it and...

Can data engineer work from home? Or do they have to be physically present at the work-site to get their data engineering job done? Let me answer this commonly asked question.

A data engineer can definitely work from home. The role of data engineer does not require the engineer to be physically present on-site. Why? because 99% of the data engineering work happens in the cloud. All you'll need is a strong Internet connection and credentials to login to your cloud accounts to build data pipelines.

Can data engineers...

Almost every engineer from the Indian middle class has considered working in a bank. Why? Traditionally, for most of Indian families - a bank job is safe, secure and gives you freedom to enjoy holidays. Also - you can settle much faster in life with a bank job. So, can engineer work in bank?

An engineer can definitely work in bank. I've had several friends who got first-class degree in engineering, then opted for MBA and then chose to work for a bank.

I'm sure you'd have engineer friends who're...