Two-wheelers with belt drives

zaveri
@zaveri-5TD6Sk โ€ข Oct 21, 2024

As we all know that motor cycles make use of chain drives as means of transmitting power from engine to rear wheel.

Now i was wondering what would happen if this chain-sprocket thing was to be replaced by belt and pulley system.

it will have its own advantages : it will be lighter, noise levels will be reduced, and it will make the vehicle designer's job easier.

Does it have any advantages though ? is this feasible ?

Replies

Welcome, guest

Join CrazyEngineers to reply, ask questions, and participate in conversations.

CrazyEngineers powered by Jatra Community Platform

  • mechky

    @mechky-jbqpJD • Jul 22, 2012

    No, belts can't be used due to following reasons:

    - Belts have much less strength than chains
    - Susceptible to slip, speed ratio doesn't remains constant
    - Periodic retensioning is required
    - Upper limit on power and speed
    - Belts deteriorate on exposure to lubricants
    - Limited life and need periodic replacement

  • zaveri

    @zaveri-5TD6Sk • Jul 22, 2012

    mechkyNo, belts can't be used due to following reasons:

    - Upper limit on power and speed
    -



    can you elaborate on this ?

  • Ramani Aswath

    @ramani-VR4O43 • Jul 22, 2012

    Belt drives depend on friction. Things may happen to reduce this at a critical moment leading to accidents. mechky's elaboration is explicit.

  • mechky

    @mechky-jbqpJD • Jul 24, 2012

    zaverican you elaborate on this ?

    speed limit is about 2000m/min and power limit is about 60kW

  • zm-i

    @zm-i-MjDXTb • Jul 26, 2012

    Some cars use timing belts. Some motorcycles also use belts. And there seems to be no problem.
    Please correct me if I am wrong. ๐Ÿ˜•

  • zaveri

    @zaveri-5TD6Sk • Jul 26, 2012

    zm-iSome cars use timing belts. Some motorcycles also use belts. And there seems to be no problem.
    Please correct me if I am wrong. ๐Ÿ˜•

    Which are those bikes

  • zm-i

    @zm-i-MjDXTb • Jul 27, 2012


    Aren't those belts?๐Ÿ˜•

  • zaveri

    @zaveri-5TD6Sk • Jul 28, 2012

    zm-i
    Aren't those belts?๐Ÿ˜•

    Yes those are belts. those are ribbed belts. they are basically used for timing. they seem to make good substitutes for chain drives in those harley davidsons .

  • zm-i

    @zm-i-MjDXTb • Jul 28, 2012

    Yes those are belts. those are ribbed belts. they are basically used for timing. they seem to make good substitutes for chain drives in those harley davidsons .

    So belts can be used, right?

  • zaveri

    @zaveri-5TD6Sk • Jul 31, 2012

    zm-iSo belts can be used, right?


    ofcourse. as you can see that they are already being used.

  • zm-i

    @zm-i-MjDXTb • Jul 31, 2012

    Yes. I do recognize that #-Link-Snipped-#. ๐Ÿ˜€ However, the first respond to your topic is a "no". So, I wonder if what #-Link-Snipped-# says is true.

    No, belts can't be used due to following reasons:

    - Belts have much less strength than chains
    - Susceptible to slip, speed ratio doesn't remains constant
    - Periodic retensioning is required
    - Upper limit on power and speed
    - Belts deteriorate on exposure to lubricants
    - Limited life and need periodic replacement

    I never really know the reason why, but I know that many have substituted chains with belts (...and of course they change the sprocket too).

  • zaveri

    @zaveri-5TD6Sk • Jul 31, 2012

    zm-iYes. I do recognize that #-Link-Snipped-#. ๐Ÿ˜€ However, the first respond to your topic is a "no". So, I wonder if what #-Link-Snipped-# says is true.



    I never really know the reason why, but I know that many have substituted chains with belts (...and of course they change the sprocket too).

    i first said no, because mechky gave strong reasons. But now since belt drives are implemented and the bikes are running normally, then there is no point in disagreeing

  • mechky

    @mechky-jbqpJD • Aug 1, 2012

    zm-iYes. I do recognize that #-Link-Snipped-#. ๐Ÿ˜€ However, the first respond to your topic is a "no". So, I wonder if what #-Link-Snipped-# says is true.



    I never really know the reason why, but I know that many have substituted chains with belts (...and of course they change the sprocket too).

    Yes, toothed belts similar to timing belts are appropriate.