CrazyEngineers Archive
Old, but evergreen and popular discussions on CrazyEngineers, presented to you in read-only mode.
@Ankita Katdare • 09 Aug, 2015
India's Department of Telecommunications recently shared a report that says Facebook's initiative does not comply with the Net Neutrality principle. The DoT report suggests that the app provides the users with access to only some websites and doesn't blocks the others. It was only natural for Facebook officials to disagree with the report. To prove their point, the company has started gathering support from Facebook users in India. Over the last week, may users saw a message on their profile timeline, which asked their opinion about provision of free basic internet services, even for people who can't afford to pay for it. The company hopes to raise all these voices to the level of Government and lets the numbers speak.

Internet.org_Logo is a Facebook-led initiative launched globally in partnership with mobile operators as well as tech giants such as Samsung and Qualcomm. In India, Reliance Communications is the big partner for launching​

It seems that Facebook is convinced that if Indians stand by in solidarity for before DoT panel presents the public opinion on its report, they could keep functional in India.

Interestingly, the DoT report which was published via the Government's official MyGov website has received around 500 views. This is being compared to the 10 lakh+ messages that were sent by Indians to TRAI to show support for proper implementation of Net Neutrality in India.

What is your stand about the Facebook's initiative to gather support for Share with us in comments below.
@Yash Pal • 10 Aug, 2015 Allowing, Airtel Zero and their present equivalents will go totally against principles of net neutrality. They have no egalitarian motives but would like to corner the market with their first mover advantage and restrict the content to what they want their users to access and derive maximum ad revenue. It is like poisoning the system.
@Anoop Kumar • 10 Aug, 2015 Everyone bragging about net neutrality ... blah blah.
What if telecom giants start giving govt online services for free (tax, weather, educational websites, farming related websites), do you still feel these should not be free and should be charged !
Do you have any idea how it much benefit to farthest corner of country?

I think govt. should tie-up with Facebook and start giving free access to at least IRCTC, ISRO weather and online courses from various institutes like IIT Lectures.

Anyway, if two companies ties up to give something completely free, nothing wrong with that. That is the concept of toll free numbers and customer cares. If a person using only whatsapp and if a company providing it for free let it be.
But yes, Internet data is data. There should not exclusive extra charging for something particular websites or service like charging voice data.
Other argument is these free giving companies using customer data and taking over market. They will use in either way and this will happen in "Net-Neutrality".

Related Posts

@jaspal rautela · Jul 15, 2012

When we say that a car has a 1150cc engine, what does it means? Why do people keep referring to the cc when looking for good vehicles? Please explain this...

@RAHUL PRASAD · Nov 15, 2012

respected sir, i am planning to give the GRE exam to pursue MS in chemical engineering abroad...the problem is that i don't know in which country should i pursue my...

@Ankita Katdare · Apr 23, 2014

IIT Bombay students see some great placements every year and the batch 2013-14 was no exception to the trend. With more than 250 companies participating in the campus placements at...

@Kaustubh Katdare · May 12, 2009

This thread is specifically for student CEans.Discuss your plans. If you are running short of ideas; you'll find something here.Keep us updated.

@satty lavanya · Sep 20, 2012

Hello, I am Satty from Vishakhapatnam. Can someone tell me about the dielectrics in capacitors? What is their role? How do they function?