CEO of Indian Search Engine Arrested For Copyright Infringement: Right Or Wrong?

Replies

• 

  silverscorpion

  I don't think the charges are justified.
  
  If that's the case, then Google should also be tried under the same charge,
  for it also provides links to illegal sites containing proprietary information.
  
  
  The site is just providing links. That is, it's just crawling the web and displaying what it finds.
  If anyone should be arrested, it is the guys who put the content online, in the first place.
• 

  optimystix

  I do not completely agree silverscorpion. It is true that google too provides links to all sorts of site but it doesnt specifically lead users to these illegal sites on purpose. Google works up its listings based on algorithms and it is the webmasters' efforts which subsequently lead a website to the top or bottom of the search results. so in that case Google is not actively involved in promoting a website. its a different matter in case of advertisements though, but I havent seen any illegal ads/promotions on google(or maybe havent noticed).
  
  Guruji on the other hand is leading people to the specific illegal download sites. its the same situation where the P2P sites lost their ground. It had to re-evolve as bittorent where the trackers could argue that the torrents on illegal stuffs were uploaded by users themselves and so they were not involved in any illegal activity(again many good sites lost their cases when sued upon) . in the similar scenario I believe Guruji.com has done something it should have and it deserves the same fate like many others before them have faced. But one must remember that this is India and people doing illegal things get away with easily.