case study

Replies

• 

  Rajni Jain

  Answer depends a lot on the question whether the that young lady had joined or not in company A and B.
  
  Now my view is:
  If I would be a senior member of company 'B' and my company's balance sheet is not in good shape, I would consider the termination option for that lady. On the businees ground, as a member of senior management team, I am there to server my company I am not there to do the charity.
  
  Also, considering that I have just hired the lady on contract and contract always starts once the lady will join my company, retention option would be tough for me. Also I will think that if lady is not loyal enough (she is having two jobs, one with A and another with my company) why I should go on the ethical grounds.
  
  So my views would go for termination.
  
  -CrazyGirl.
• 

  durga ch

  ok.
  Firslt one can contract to a company . I have personlaly known people who have thier own companies (small scaled though) and contracted to the present company i am working for.
  Also, you can consider that that lady being from company A and then contracting to compnay B through company A . Her parent company has fired her, she can always go to company B for work.
  
  P/S: I gave my answer as to-be-terminated, but on return trip home I released may be she could have been retained. Firing should be last option.
• 

  Anil Jain

  Durga - Why you gave answer as Termination at the first place?? And what made you realised that she can be retained.
  
  -CB
• 

  Saandeep Sreerambatla

  IF the woman is Intelligent, As I am the senior management of Company - B , if she loses job in A I would hire her!!
  
  My answer is retain!!
• 

  durga ch

  Persopnal experience I should say
  
  I knew a Solution desinger ( obvious that he is precious to compnay) who was a contractor to the compnay since 11 yrs. Contractors are paid more than permanent staff , hence his contract as terminated as soon as the project went live.
  SO I was impulsive enough to say terminate .
  BVut I forgot about one more character whose contract was extended though she was a contractor to the compnay, only based on reason that her work is continous and not project based. Dont guess, that was me.I complelty forgot hat my contract was extended this actaully put me in more dilema when I was travellign back home. Iw as wonderign how my manager took the descision
• 

  durga ch

  English-Scared

  IF the woman is Intelligent, As I am the senior management of Company - B , if she loses job in A I would hire her!!
  
  My answer is retain!!

  she is intelligent, but her knwolege is not applicble in the project and currenlty you really dont have visiblity for her. Then?
• 

  Prasad Ajinkya

  If I am a senior official in company B, and I have already made an offer on a contractual basis for a scientist, then its obviously for an intended outcome.
  
  If with the cost cutting, the outcome still holds, then I will hire her - possibly I might try to negotiate more on the remuneration. But I would retain her.
  If the outcome goes, so does she.