3 Idiots Vs Five Point Someone

Replies

• 

  Manish Goyal

  Alas! I have neither watched the movie nor read the book..
  but i am very anxious to know about your views ceans.
  I want to know a person named 'vidhu vinod chopra' who gave us message of 'Gandhi giri'
  can cheat someone or not?
• 

  sarveshgupta

  The point is it is the Gandhigiri style of gaining publicity and arousing the audiences curosity and interest 😁
• 

  Anil Jain

  I have read the Novel and also seen the movie...
  
  My 2 cents on this, movie is a bit influenced from the novel. However, as per me author (Chetan Bhagat) or anybody shouldn't claim that they have copied the movie script with novel (As there are a lots of change in the movie script than the novel).
  
  -CB
• 

  Prasad Ajinkya

  Heh .. I dont see what the debate is all about ... especially after going through this site.
  
  #-Link-Snipped-#
• 

  Kaustubh Katdare

  I've read the book and watched the movie. Few parts of the movie have been taken from the book.
  
  There's no point in debating about similarities or differences. Chetan Bhagat & Aamir Khan may have a deal on this. Create controversay, media buzz et al and get more people to watch the movie.
• 

  Mahesh Dahale

  The_Big_K

  I've read the book and watched the movie. Few parts of the movie have been taken from the book.
  
  There's no point in debating about similarities or differences. Chetan Bhagat & Aamir Khan may have a deal on this. Create controversay, media buzz et al and get more people to watch the movie.

  
  Ya Big_k, you are right...
• 

  Gurjeet Singh

  i have read the book and watched movie also,yes we can say that movie is influenced by the novel to some extent 😀
• 

  sarveshgupta

  The_Big_K

  I've read the book and watched the movie. Few parts of the movie have been taken from the book.
  
  There's no point in debating about similarities or differences. Chetan Bhagat & Aamir Khan may have a deal on this. Create controversay, media buzz et al and get more people to watch the movie.

  Well you are right, BigK
  
  that is what I said in my second post in this thread too
• 

  vik001ind

  Both the book & the movie are very much different from each other. But the movie sounds like it was made intentionally to divert it from actual story in the book . So of those addition don't fit well in the story like the operation scene & are quite difficult to digest by Indian janta . Altogether the movie is good but writer should be given little more credit as the movie was made by taking the book as its base. And after the movie got released, the director asks the writer "hum apke hai kaun"! Thats not fair yaar!
  I don't think it was publicity stunt!
• 

  callyD

  I second vik001ind's opinion. Movie is definitely based on five point someone... you can not take credit the brilliance of Chetan.

  
  ​