Replies
Welcome, guest
Join CrazyEngineers to reply, ask questions, and participate in conversations.
CrazyEngineers powered by Jatra Community Platform
-
@thebigk • Jul 15, 2006
Current (temp.) ranking system -
For the curious minds -
Format: Title-Min.Posts
CE-New Team Member-1
CE-Team Member-10
CE-Regular Team Member-20
CEan-Addicted-50
CEan-Senior-100
CEan-Super Senior-200
CEan-Expert-300
We'll update the ranks once we think of a new (& better) system.
-The Big K- -
@aashima-eO93l9 • Jul 16, 2006
The_Big_KFor the curious minds -
Format: Title-Min.Posts
CE-New Team Member-1
CE-Team Member-10
CE-Regular Team Member-20
CEan-Addicted-50
CEan-Senior-100
CEan-Super Senior-200
CEan-Expert-300
We'll update the ranks once we think of a new (& better) system.
-The Big K-nice one biggie.. i liked the new ranking system.... its good.... but is it possible to add ranks at 150 and 250 as well???
-
@thebigk • Jul 16, 2006
it is!
Everything is possible π , but do we really need it?
If yes, what ranks shall we assign?
-The Big K- -
@aashima-eO93l9 • Jul 16, 2006
well...
well the reason i thot its required is because u sort of get an encouragement wen u get a better rank.... waiting to complete a 100 to improve yer designation takes long time.. thats y.. but its just a suggestion.. not a compulsion -
@thebigk • Jul 16, 2006
new thought
aashimawell the reason i thot its required is because u sort of get an encouragement wen u get a better rank.... waiting to complete a 100 to improve yer designation takes long time.. thats y.. but its just a suggestion.. not a compulsion
That's true, but it also encourages to post just for the sake of posting! Ranks, I think is the surest way of generating spam.
On a recent thought, how about completely removing the post count based -ranking system and only having special ranks depending upon the contribution to the forum?
I think this will encourage CEans to bring quality content and not just the quantity!
-The Big K- -
@aashima-eO93l9 • Jul 16, 2006
fine
The_Big_KThat's true, but it also encourages to post just for the sake of posting! Ranks, I think is the surest way of generating spam.
On a recent thought, how about completely removing the post count based -ranking system and only having special ranks depending upon the contribution to the forum?
I think this will encourage CEans to bring quality content and not just the quantity!
-The Big K-not a bad idea.. thats true that most of us post just for the heck of it.... it'll be better to rank on the basis of contribution but how to do dat?? do u have any way out for that???
-
@thebigk • Jul 16, 2006
note
We can have Ranks like
CEan-Techie ( for those who add technical posts )
CEan-Geek ( who is into geeky stuff )
CEan-Value Adder ( π ) - For those who bring in overall quality
..
... and like that. We will have to think about it. Moreover, the ranks will have to be assigned manually. There won't be any automated system to do that for us. So its going to be quite some effort π
-The Big K- -
@aashima-eO93l9 • Jul 16, 2006
well
but then i guess it can crop up a feeling of biasing and dissatisfaction... i mean we won't have a proper and justified mechanism then.. watsay biggie? -
@thebigk • Jul 16, 2006
how about?
aashimabut then i guess it can crop up a feeling of biasing and dissatisfaction... i mean we won't have a proper and justified mechanism then.. watsay biggie?
I agree.
Well, things won't be in place at start. How about having 2-3 regular CEans to decide what rank to give to a particular memeber? We can always decide that in conferences.
No doubt this is a challenge for us, not a problem !
-The Big K- -
@aashima-eO93l9 • Jul 16, 2006
well...
The_Big_KI agree.
Well, things won't be in place at start. How about having 2-3 regular CEans to decide what rank to give to a particular memeber? We can always decide that in conferences.
No doubt this is a challenge for us, not a problem !
-The Big K-well wat about entirely one person to decide that??? wat abt our admin to the job???
-
@thebigk • Jul 16, 2006
break!
... will do.
But .......Gimme a Break ! π
-The Big K- -
@aashima-eO93l9 • Jul 16, 2006
The_Big_K... will do.
But .......Gimme a Break ! π
-The Big K-no probz.. take yer time... but make sure ur comfortable enuff to do that all alone!!! am there for any assistance if u require any ;-)
-
@thebigk • Jul 18, 2006
a thought
aashimano probz.. take yer time... but make sure ur comfortable enuff to do that all alone!!! am there for any assistance if u require any ;-)
Why did you say that? the 'by default' list begins with your name π
I did think over removing the post count based ranking system and it makes perfect sense. I hope many CEans will agree with me.
Instead, I guess, having a contribution based ranking system will be great. But as aashima pointed, it will be difficult to manage. I see following advantages -
- The new ranking system will not encourage the new CEans to post just to get a higher rank on the forum.
- Hopefully, it will bring quality content on the forum.
- Why do we need people with 'Higher'/'Lower' ranks?
Let me know what you feel.
-The Big K- -
@aashima-eO93l9 • Jul 18, 2006
me ready for the new ranking system... the best advantage of the same is it'll improve the quality value of the forums.... something that is most important.... and thats true..."why actually do we need the ranks??"
it wud be great if implemented in right and correct form.... -
@jerry-5wPKU7 • Jul 19, 2006
makes sense
Hello, I have been away for a while.
I agree that we need not have member ranks based on number of posts. Instead, everyone should have a common rank 'CE-Team Member'.
Of course special ranks are welcome. We do not need ranks. The only way this community can grow is by having better content and caring members. I am glad to see that we already have members who are active and taking the forum to a new height. -
@deejay-Nbg7hJ • Jul 19, 2006
Agree to what you are saying Jerry...Ranking should not be there
-
@crook-0PFkJv • Jul 19, 2006
yess!
I'm game for ranks independent of posts . What are the special ranks that are being considered?
I suggest CEan-Spammer π π
Crook π
-welcome Deejay, please post your introduction in the introduction section -
@aashima-eO93l9 • Jul 19, 2006
well....
crookI'm game for ranks independent of posts . What are the special ranks that are being considered?
I suggest CEan-Spammer π π
Crook π
-welcome Deejay, please post your introduction in the introduction sectionwell to designate the boring thread and replies one... we can go for... CE-nerd
π :sshhh: -
@sristi-483Qff • Jul 22, 2006
well im with ranks not based on number of posts..
-
@thebigk • Jul 22, 2006
Good
Good, it seems that many of us are in favor of ranks that are not post count based.
Now, can we have suggestions regarding the Ranks? I thought of -
CEan-Techie : For those who contribute technical stuff. More ideas are welcome.
-The Big K- -
@aashima-eO93l9 • Jul 23, 2006
okk
CE addicted
for the one who visits it frequently... well i know its repeted but i found it pretty nice.... thats just a suggestion though... not a compulsion π -
@thebigk • Jul 23, 2006
CE-Addicted is my favorite too π . Probably this title can be given to the one who is frequent on the forums.
More thoughts, ideas are welcome !
-The Big K- -
@rick-JybHX8 • Aug 12, 2006
So what is the final outcome of this discussion? π
-
@thebigk • Aug 12, 2006
The status is still 'TBD' π
I'll update the forums with new ranking system soon.
-The Big K- -
@aashima-eO93l9 • Aug 16, 2006
okay
The_Big_KThe status is still 'TBD' π
I'll update the forums with new ranking system soon.
-The Big K-do let us know biggie in case of any help we may provide you regarding the same π
-
@thebigk • Aug 16, 2006
aashimado let us know biggie in case of any help we may provide you regarding the same π
Sure,
We need ideas on special ranks that we may have. We will have special ranks for the CEans who add value to the community. So, what rank do we assign to the CEans who regularly bring in quality content?
-The Big K- -
@aashima-eO93l9 • Aug 16, 2006
The_Big_KSure,
We need ideas on special ranks that we may have. We will have special ranks for the CEans who add value to the community. So, what rank do we assign to the CEans who regularly bring in quality content?
-The Big K-How about CE-activist?? π
-
@thebigk • Aug 17, 2006
New Ranking System is in place!
Hello CEans!
The new ranking system is in place. Now, we will have two post count based ranks -
New CE-Team Member ( For > 1 posts )
CE- Regular Team Member ( for >50 posts )
Further,
Special ranks will be assigned to the CEans who add value to the forums. Special ranks are manually assigned and are not based on the post count.
-The Big K- -
@CrazyBoy • Aug 17, 2006
Biigi one small suggestion, however don't have much ideas about ranking but saw a small typo ...:
Good should be GOD ππ
--Crazy -
@thebigk • Aug 18, 2006
crazyboyBiigi one small suggestion, however don't have much ideas about ranking but saw a small typo ...:
Good should be GOD ππ
--CrazyYou mean 'The GOD Administrator' :shock:
... Go(o)d Save Me !
-The Big K- -
@neha-3vibjn • Aug 18, 2006
The_Big_KHello CEans!
Special ranks will be assigned to the CEans who add value to the forums. Special ranks are manually assigned and are not based on the post count.
-The Big K-Thats a pretty good step..it will help in decreasing spams I guess
-
@thebigk • Aug 19, 2006
Reducing spam is not the aim. Rather getting quality content is our first priority. We don't have a way to reduce spam π
The CEans who bring quality content will be awarded special ranks.
-The Big K-