View Feed
group-icon
Coffee Room
Discuss anything here - everything that you wish to discuss with fellow engineers.
12831 Members
Join this group to post and comment.

try this BUZZLE... really good one

A soap company has produced 10 boxes of soap. Each box contains 100 bars of soap, and is supposed to weigh 30kgs. But each of the bars of soap in one of the boxes is 1g more than it should be. You have a digital scale that you can use for reading the weight only ONCE. How do you know which box weighs more?
​
is it that hard !!!
komputergeek
komputergeek • Nov 22, 2008
Can he use any means to compare weights of 2 boxes?
If he can then he will take any random box and weigh it.If it is 30kg +100g (I am bad in maths.Still i am a engineer 😉 ) then he got the solution else he will compare that box with all other boxes to get the answer.
sorry man, u can use the digital scale only once...think again:wink:
Kaustubh Katdare
Kaustubh Katdare • Nov 22, 2008
ElectricStriker
A soap company has produced 10 boxes of soap. Each box contains 100 bars of soap, and is supposed to weigh 30kgs. But each of the bars of soap in one of the boxes is 1g more than it should be. You have a digital scale that you can use for reading the weight only ONCE. How do you know which box weighs more?
​
My take -

Name the boxes from 1 - 10. Take out as many bars from each box as its number. That is, 1 bar from the box #1, 2 from box # 2, and so on till 10 bars from box # 10

Then weigh them together. The difference in the expected weight and the actual weight should shout the number of the faulty box. [​IMG]

Alright? :hehehe:
durga ch
durga ch • Nov 22, 2008
biggie!! I understood your solution... if the expected wt is 1 gm more than actual wt the bar is from first box... if its 2 gms more its in second box... and so on.. good till here...but tell me what if all the bars are identical?I mean same size and shape??

1 sec I guess I know how..

arrange them in a form of a pyramid while weighing... ie 10 bars of box 10 in the lowest line,9bas from box 9 above it ..and so on...till 1 bar form boc 1 on the top..
so depending on what is the excess weight we can determine the box 😀

P.S:I know i just elaborated your solution 😁
Kaustubh Katdare
Kaustubh Katdare • Nov 22, 2008
durga
biggie!! I understood your solution... if the expected wt is 1 gm more than actual wt the bar is from first box... if its 2 gms more its in second box... and so on.. good till here...but tell me what if all the bars are identical?I mean same size and shape??

1 sec I guess I know how..

arrange them in a form of a pyramid while weighing... ie 10 bars of box 10 in the lowest line,9bas from box 9 above it ..and so on...till 1 bar form boc 1 on the top..
so depending on what is the excess weight we can determine the box 😀

P.S:I know i just elaborated your solution 😁
No matter how you arrange them - the difference in the weight will give you the box number. 😁
durga ch
durga ch • Nov 22, 2008
The_Big_K
No matter how you arrange them - the difference in the weight will give you the box number. 😁
got it!!!😉
WeLL DoNe... great thinkin'

Share this content on your social channels -