View Feed
group-icon
Coffee Room
Discuss anything here - everything that you wish to discuss with fellow engineers.
12834 Members
Join this group to post and comment.
Aruwin
Aruwin • Jan 23, 2012

solving an equation to plot a graph

Hi everyone.Someone please help me solve this problem.I am stucked,really.This is actually part 2 of a question where part one is already solved by getting the equation needed to draw the graph.
And here is the equation:
(x^2+y^2)(x+y)=2axy
and the plotting table is as shown in the image:
[​IMG]

and a hint is that when x and y are at their higest values, the equation
(x^2+y^2)(x+y)=0 and hence,x+y=0

but how do I solve this to plot the graph?
It's a bit confusing to me.
What do theta and r value signify here?
Aruwin
Aruwin • Jan 23, 2012
the angle and radius i suppose...
Yes, I can make that out.
But confused which is x value and which is y value. 😔
Aruwin
Aruwin • Jan 23, 2012
Dancer_Engineer
Yes, I can make that out.
But confused which is x value and which is y value. 😔
I am confused too but that is the answer given 😔
Well, can you try and figure it out your own way without referring to the answers?Perhaps from there you may get something?
Post the complete question, both part 1 and part 2.
Aruwin
Aruwin • Jan 23, 2012
Dancer_Engineer
Post the complete question, both part 1 and part 2.
OK,but you're gonna have to wait because I have to write the solution manually cuz it is easier for me.
pranav_vanarp
pranav_vanarp • Jan 23, 2012
try putting x = r * cos (theta)
y = r * sin (theta) .
equation becomes
r^3 (cos (theta) + sin (theta) ) = 2(r^2)acos(theta)sin(theta) ;

=> r(cos(theta) + sin(theta)) = 2a cos(theta)sin(theta)
=> 1/sin(theta) + 1/cos(theta) = 2a / r

if we try theta = pi/4 and r = a/sq root(2) . as the image suggests ,
the equation does seem to be satisfied

Thus one solution is x = a/2 and y = a/2.
Aruwin
Aruwin • Jan 23, 2012
So here is the question and the solution of the first part.The question is actually in japanese so I had to translate it into english so you can understand.

There is a rectangle paper ABCD and let point B be the peak as it is folded.The paper is folded at line EF.Let P be the shifted point of B. If PE+PF= a, how is the curve P drawn??

[​IMG]
[​IMG]
Aruwin
Aruwin • Jan 23, 2012
pranav_vanarp
try putting x = r * cos (theta)
y = r * sin (theta) .
equation becomes
r^3 (cos (theta) + sin (theta) ) = 2(r^2)acos(theta)sin(theta) ;

=> r(cos(theta) + sin(theta)) = 2a cos(theta)sin(theta)
=> 1/sin(theta) + 1/cos(theta) = 2a / r

if we try theta = pi/4 and r = a/sq root(2) . as the image suggests ,
the equation does seem to be satisfied
but why do we have to put x = r*cos theta?
Is it valid?
pranav_vanarp
pranav_vanarp • Jan 23, 2012
of course it is valid.
in any equation you can put x = rcos theta
y = rsin theta.

the equation is of 2 variables. we are merely transforming the co-ordinate system.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_o..._Cartesian_coordinates_from_polar_coordinates

where did you get the table in first post from. the one containing values of r and theta.
Aruwin
Aruwin • Jan 23, 2012
pranav_vanarp
of course it is valid.
in any equation you can put x = rcos theta
y = rsin theta.

the equation is of 2 variables. we are merely transforming the co-ordinate system.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_o..._Cartesian_coordinates_from_polar_coordinates

where did you get the table in first post from. the one containing values of r and theta.
the teacher showed it.So,how do I plot the points??How does the graph gonna turn out?I am so lost 😔
pranav_vanarp
pranav_vanarp • Jan 23, 2012
do you only want the solutions to the equation or the entire graph ?

Plotting r-theta graph will be easier than plotting x-y graph.
of course the shape will be same. Only procedure will be different.
Your equation here is
(1/sin(theta) + 1/cos(theta)) = 2a/r .

Notice that you will have to plot r versus theta.
Vary theta from 0 to 2pi and find what values of r you get. Then mark the various points.
For ex in above equation at theta = 0 , r = 0. (i.e the point x=0 , y = 0)
at theta = pi/4 r = a/sq root(2). (i. e the point x=y= a/2 ).

You getting the drift ?
Aruwin
Aruwin • Jan 23, 2012
pranav_vanarp
do you only want the solutions to the equation or the entire graph ?

Plotting r-theta graph will be easier than plotting x-y graph.
of course the shape will be same. Only procedure will be different.
Your equation here is
(1/sin(theta) + 1/cos(theta)) = 2a/r .

Notice that you will have to plot r versus theta.
Oh thank you thank you!!Well, I want the solutions only for the equation because when the equation is solved, then I can just plot r against theta.
pranav_vanarp
pranav_vanarp • Jan 23, 2012
Aruwin
Oh thank you thank you!!Well, I want the solutions only for the equation because when the equation is solved, then I can just plot r against theta.
Ok. Well it is good to know how to plot equations in r and theta. It simplifies matters in some cases in some cases it does not.

Anyways this is how your plot should look for a = 1.
https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=plot+(x^2+++y^2)(+x+++y)+=+2(x*y)
Aruwin
Aruwin • Jan 23, 2012
pranav_vanarp
Ok. Well it is good to know how to plot equations in r and theta. It simplifies matters in some cases in some cases it does not.

Anyways this is how your plot should look for a = 1.
https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=plot (x^2 + y^2)( x + y) = 2(x*y)
Oh no,wait a minute.Now what do I do with a??Can I assume a=1 always?
pranav_vanarp
pranav_vanarp • Jan 23, 2012
I think not. The equation needs an 'a'. That plot was just to illustrate for a = 1.

But 'a' is a constant , so you don't need to worry about it too much. You have to plot in terms of 'a'.
i.e at theta = pi/4 , r = a/sq root(2) (or x = y = a/2).
Why don't you try google graphs? It would help you plot the graph of the equation na???
Aruwin
Aruwin • Jan 24, 2012
pranav_vanarp
do you only want the solutions to the equation or the entire graph ?

Plotting r-theta graph will be easier than plotting x-y graph.
of course the shape will be same. Only procedure will be different.
Your equation here is
(1/sin(theta) + 1/cos(theta)) = 2a/r .

Notice that you will have to plot r versus theta.
Vary theta from 0 to 2pi and find what values of r you get. Then mark the various points.
For ex in above equation at theta = 0 , r = 0. (i.e the point x=0 , y = 0)
at theta = pi/4 r = a/sq root(2). (i. e the point x=y= a/2 ).

You getting the drift ?
Hey, I have one doubt here. In the table graph,When theta=0,r=0 but according to the equation
(1/sin(theta) + 1/cos(theta)) = 2a/r ,isn't it supposed to be that r=2a???
Because cos(0)=1,am I right??
Same goes to when theta=pi,why is r=0 and not 2a?
Because sin(pi)=1

And can you explain to me why is when theta=3pi/4,r=+/- infinity????
How come it becomes infinity?
Hello.

Aruwin
Hey, I have one doubt here. In the table graph,When theta=0,r=0 but according to the equation
(1/sin(theta) + 1/cos(theta)) = 2a/r ,isn't it supposed to be that r=2a???
Because cos(0)=1,am I right??
You seem to be ignoring sin(theta). rewrite the said equation as
r = 2a(sin(theta)cos(theta))/(sin(theta) + cos(theta)) ----- (i)
putting theta = 0
you get
r = 2a(sin(0)cos(0)/(sin(0) + cos(0)). Similarly for theta = pi use equation (i). Earlier form of equation must have confused you. There 1/sin(0) term was present ,you missed it.


r = 2a(sin(3pi/4)cos(3pi/4))/(sin 3pi/4 + cos 3pi/4). Denominator is zero. Hence you approach infinity for r. I don't know why +/- infinity is given to you. Perhaps when you approach theta from right side of 3pi/4 you get + infinity and when approaced from left side of 3pi/4 you get -infinity (or other way around).
Aruwin
Aruwin • Jan 24, 2012
Deepesh Bagwale
Hello.



You seem to be ignoring sin(theta). rewrite the said equation as
r = 2a(sin(theta)cos(theta))/(sin(theta) + cos(theta)) ----- (i)
putting theta = 0
you get
r = 2a(sin(0)cos(0)/(sin(0) + cos(0)). Similarly for theta = pi use equation (i). Earlier form of equation must have confused you. There 1/sin(0) term was present ,you missed it.
Oh my,you are right!Didn't realize that mistake before.Thanks.Hey,can you please help me out with my othe post about Leaf of Descartes?

Share this content on your social channels -