Is ABS really a needed safety system for Indian road conditions?

Replies

• 

  lal

  I actually thought it works perfectly on dry roads. Or at least, that is what I've read till date. In snow and rain ABS is said to perform less effectively.
  
  But, the technology has developed a lot and in present scenario performs quite well in all challenging conditions. Why do you doubt whether ABS is effective on Indian roads? What is the limiting factor that is present only on Indian roads?
• 

  Sarathkumar Chandrasekaran

  I read that It was more effective in ice or snow filled roads where car wheel tend to skid when brake is applied.ABS helps to handle better during this situation.
  This was what i read.Sorry if it is wrong and correct me sir
• 

  Sarathkumar Chandrasekaran

  Waiting for valuable comments from CEans:
  #-Link-Snipped-# #-Link-Snipped-# #-Link-Snipped-# #-Link-Snipped-# and all other CEans are free to express their views
• 

  Kaustubh Katdare

  I'm not really familiar with the way ABS work; but I haven't experienced wheels getting locked. Can someone tell me if ABS influence the costs by huge margin?
• 

  Pensu

  As far as I know, ABS stops the wheels from skidding on smooth surfaces when you apply sudden brakes, like in the case of snow or rain, as you mentioned. I think it's a good security measure, coz let's be frank, roads are filled with idiots and you never know when you will have to push the brake hard! In which case ABS will not freeze the wheel, instead the mechanism will stop it in small intervals, like stop-run-stop-run, something like that, which in turn helps to avoid the skidding and toppling in some cases.
  
  As far as indian roads are concerned, yes there is no snow, but there is chance of water when it rains, so I don't think having an extra security measure will hurt.
  
  Coming to costs, yes, it does make a big difference. One of my friends went for car hunting a few weeks ago, and I accompanied him, turns out ABS and airbags can make a difference of 40,000 - 70,000 in the cost of the vehicle!
• 

  Sarathkumar Chandrasekaran

  Researched for many websites on the issue whether it is possible to install ABS in non ABS cars and the answer is simple.It was quite expensive, complicated as it involves modification of wheels to accomodate sensors, creating path for wiring, coding etc.Many experts suggested to buy a ABS equipped car rather than installing new one.
  
  #-Link-Snipped-# I am too curious. to know price of ABS system as oli didnt get a answer through net.
• 

  Sarathkumar Chandrasekaran

  #-Link-Snipped-#
  Thanks for interesting info .So advanced cars always come in package like ABD+Airbags.
  Do you know cost of AbS alone?
  Thanks
• 

  Pensu

  #-Link-Snipped-# : No idea, man! And as far as I have seen, they don't add them separately. Either you go for a car without ABS and airbags, or you buy one already equipped with them.
• 

  Amit Krupal

  ABS systems consist of 4 primary components:
  ABS Controller
  ABS Speed sensors
  ABS Modulator/Valves
  ABS Pumps
  
  ABS systems were designed to increase stopping performance. Skidding wheels have less traction and therefore take longer to stop than non-skidding wheels. Skidding wheels also put the vehicle in more danger of accident due to the lack of control. By monitoring and controlling the rate of deceleration of each wheel anti lock brake systems avoid this skidding.
• 

  Sarathkumar Chandrasekaran

  Thanks for info #-Link-Snipped-#.
  Your view on this discussion whether it is fit for Ibdian roads or not¿
• 

  Anoop Kumar

  SarathKumar Chandrasekaran

  Thanks for info #-Link-Snipped-#.
  Your view on this discussion whether it is fit for Ibdian roads or not¿

  Yes, wheel get chocked while applying breaks in panic condition when driver keep pressing break to stop vehicle. To avoid this you need to pump the break or get ABS.
  
  Following video is no accurate but overall this is how ABS works.
  Prevents chocking of breaks which prevents wheel to bend in either direction.
  In two wheeler abs works by applying rear and front break simultaneously
  
• 

  Vikram S Bargah

  SarathKumar Chandrasekaran

  We know that ABS- Anti lock braking system has been a good safety system which helps to stop the locking of wheel during braking which predominantly takes place in cold countries where cars often skid while applying brakes.This works with the help of sensors which continuously track the locking of wheel and the ECU helps to drive the car with better handling during handling .
  But is this effective in Indian road conditions ?
  Should we spend more on other important safety systems?

  ABS cost heavy on pocket but its an important safety feature too.
  
  As far as Indian Road conditions are concerned ,I think it should be made mandatory in some specific regions like Hill Areas.
  
  Hill roads are more prone to skid during Rainy season & Winter season which may cause fatal accident. Hence all the Small & Heavy vehicles (Personal + Commercial) running on hill roads should have ABS installed .
• 

  Vikram S Bargah

  SarathKumar Chandrasekaran

  #-Link-Snipped-#
  Thanks for interesting info .So advanced cars always come in package like ABD+Airbags.
  Do you know cost of AbS alone?
  Thanks

  
  Think this may help : #-Link-Snipped-#