Bullet Train To Run In India On Mumbai-Ahmedabad Route Using Japanese Technology

Replies

• 

  Anil Jain

  Probably success of Delhi Metro, has influenced them think that Japanese can manage (trains) better than Indian??
  
  -CB
• 

  Anand Tamariya

  I'd rather trust a proven foreign technology than put several lives in jeopardy for sake of nationalism.
• 

  Kaustubh Katdare

  Anand Tamariya

  I'd rather trust a proven foreign technology than put several lives in jeopardy for sake of nationalism.

  Did Japan jeopardise Japanese when they created bullet train?
• 

  Anil Jain

  Japan was the first country to have bullet train in their tech kitty. Didn't have much of the options.
  
  Please do not take it otherwise, on Top of that they do not have height of corruptions as unfortunately we have in India. There would be "SO" many lives that may travel in those bullet trains.
  
  NOTE: Though no connection with bullet train, but Recently this happened in India.. (2013 Thane Building Collapse). I read the specifications, and I can't tell you what they had used.. 😔
  
  -CB
• 

  Anand Tamariya

  Kaustubh Katdare

  Did Japan jeopardise Japanese when they created bullet train?

  #-Link-Snipped-#
  
  Indian private sector makes more profit than public sector yet Prestige builders (in the above article) were building a sub-standard building. You can only hear frustration whenever IRCTC is brought into conversation - and we are considered to be a dominant player in IT industry. Sorry, if this is Indian engineering, I pick Japanese any day!!
• 

  Kaustubh Katdare

  #-Link-Snipped-# : I know the point you are making. Administration & engineering are two different terms. Looks at the roads IRB has been building in Maharashtra and Gujarat. They're top-notch.
  
  Engineering mistakes are different and so are the mishaps happening because of bad administration. Ultimately, it'll be the Indian officials and workers who'll be setting up the infrastructure under Japanese guidance. So if we only want Japanese Guidance, why not engineer the stuff in India itself? If that doesn't happen, India will NEVER have the confidence to be an engineering hub.
• 

  vikaskumar11233

  If you will talk about the administration, than it is a huge thing and not solvable, can see the example of CWG 2010 bridge, which was made by ARMY in the end, So private sector is good as #-Link-Snipped-# said.
• 

  Anand Tamariya

  Kaustubh Katdare

  #-Link-Snipped-# : So if we only want Japanese Guidance, why not engineer the stuff in India itself?

  Engineers design and workers build. So if it's Japanese Guidance, it's Japanese engineering only.
• 

  Sanoj Rajan

  Kaustubh Katdare

  #-Link-Snipped-# : Looks at the roads IRB has been building in Maharashtra and Gujarat. They're top-notch.

  I beg to differ. Staying in ahmedabad since past 21 years, and i have hardly come across a couple or few 'TOP-NOTCH' roads !!
  
  Speaking of Administration?? They RE-surface a road, only to be dug up again in just next few weeks. It will then be not touched till the monsoon. And if they do, they would make sure that it won't last till the monsoon ends !! That speaks of the Engineering !!
• 

  Sanoj Rajan

  Lets talk about the Metro itself !!
  3 years since the MEGA (Metro- Link Express for Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad) project has been launched, and the only thing they have done on-site is: big hoardings indicating that Metro would be going through here !!
  
  Well, i agree, it takes time !!
  But how about this?? The Metro's route and the BRTS's route are parallel on major stretches !! Well, if it was Metro, then why BRTS?? If it was for BRTS, then why Metro???
  
  I guess, that would clear everyone's stand about the administration here !!