Should there be a dress code in colleges or at workplaces?

Discussion in 'Debate Masterminds' started by Kaustubh Katdare, Mar 16, 2008.

    • The MOD Squad

    Kaustubh Katdare The Good Admin

    Message Count:
    28,457
    Ratings Received:
    +2,860
    Engineering Discipline:
    Electrical
    Let's see what our CEans have to say about this.

    Many colleges and corporates have a dress-code policy. Some of the colleges have their own uniform and some of the big corporates ask you to wear business formals on Monday - Tuesday, allow semi-formals on Wednesday - Thursday and casuals on Fridays.

    Do you think you attire has anything to do with the way you work? Do you think dress-codes actually reflect the culture of an organization? Do you think its better to have a dress-code at workplaces?

    Let the world know your opinion!
    • The MOD Squad

    gohm Moderator

    Message Count:
    2,768
    Ratings Received:
    +33
    Engineering Discipline:
    Mechanical
    I personally do not favor dress codes or uniforms. If it is a public organization than a big no to dress codes. A private organization has the right to inforce any dress codes they wish. I think unless you are dealing directly with the public or clients than what does it matter what you wear. The personal freedom and increased comfort can improve productivity, that's why a lot of cutting edge businesses have no policy at all (like IT).

    kidakaka Maniac

    Message Count:
    814
    Ratings Received:
    +50
    Engineering Discipline:
    Computer Science
    Well, dress codes do reflect on the culture and the office environment. There is something to that.

    But as long as one is not working in a role, where they are expected to adhere to certain norms e.g a BD person, a CEO, etc :) ... its ok to then dress as per your comfort.

    The CEO of one of the firms I used to work with used to say, I dont care what clothes you wear to office, as long as you wear them!!

    And thats what matters :)
    • The MOD Squad

    ash Moderator

    Message Count:
    4,455
    Ratings Received:
    +34
    Engineering Discipline:
    Communications
    Man, If I was the boss of a company, I don't want my employees to be too slacking in their dress code. At least maintain some professionalism! I believe its about balance; not too strict as to confine creativity, but not too slacking to make employees lazy.

    I suppose I agree the dress code is a reflection of the culture of the institution. Think about the military; one of the ways to instill discipline is to make sure the uniforms are immaculate.
    • Like Like x 1

    kidakaka Maniac

    Message Count:
    814
    Ratings Received:
    +50
    Engineering Discipline:
    Computer Science
    Fair enough, but theres a difference between discipline and professionalism. As long as the job gets done, why have strict issues about what you get to wear and what you dont. Such rules cut individuality, creativity ... thats precisely why its needed in the army.

    Take Google for example, they do not have any dress code ... same goes for Microsoft ... developers can choose to come in sneakers and shorts, if they want to.

    So lets look at the objective, getting the job done. If that is independent of what you wear, then why have a dress code? If that is not, then please look into having a dress code.
    • The MOD Squad

    Kaustubh Katdare The Good Admin

    Message Count:
    28,457
    Ratings Received:
    +2,860
    Engineering Discipline:
    Electrical
    Well, I believe that the dress code doesn't have any effect on the way people work. However, it is an indicator of 'discipline'.

    As Kidakaka said, there is a difference between discipline and professionalism. In my opinion, professionalism is related to the way of working and it should not be affected by the way you dress.

    I was wondering why Indian IT Giant Infosys asks its employees to follow different dress codes on different days of week ( Friday -> Casuals can be understood ;) )

    friendster7 Certified CEan

    Message Count:
    398
    Ratings Received:
    +2
    I do not favor dress codes or uniforms.it depends on the individual.his likes r dislikes.it is always good to change and try out different color and style..

    and it will be good for market also..ha ha ha ...(just kidding)..
    • The MOD Squad

    ash Moderator

    Message Count:
    4,455
    Ratings Received:
    +34
    Engineering Discipline:
    Communications
    I knew one of you will bring google up ;)

    Oh well, I still think you should have some sorta dress code in a workplace. That doesnt mean a specific colour or style. Just means: wear decently. That decency is the "uniformity" here, but you are no restricted to the colour you wear.

    And I think discipline does play a little role, if not a big one. Coming to work on time, not extending the lunch time, going home late to finish work etc. I'm sure its quite common in India to set a meeting at a particular time, but the others come late. Happens often here in Malaysia! I think im going off topic here with the discipline stuff. But I think a certain dress code would help with that.

    I mentioned the military to link the aspect of work and dress code. So, the dress code is a MUST for some types of work. Other examples include: air stewardess.

    I think im jumbling my points up.. my apologies for that!

    just2rock Certified CEan

    Message Count:
    431
    Ratings Received:
    +1
    Engineering Discipline:
    Electronics & Communications
    crap...cant find anything else;-)

    just2rock Certified CEan

    Message Count:
    431
    Ratings Received:
    +1
    Engineering Discipline:
    Electronics & Communications
    Thats true Kidakaka:p....engineers or any professionals are hirred nly to fulfill desired work...so what to do with dress code...we Stay in Democratic country..so dont know about the rest of world;-)

    crazysandy Certified CEan

    Message Count:
    14
    Ratings Received:
    +0
    Engineering Discipline:
    Electronics & Telecommunications
    Uniform's are suitable only in few places. As ash mentioned uniform's are must in military because we can easily differentiate enimies and our people while we are on war. And wherever hospitality is there dress code will be better. In IT companies do you expect any Enemies to differentiate or do you want to provide hospitality to anyone?:rolleyes: According to me its no. In work especially in IT companies its better to wear clothes as per your comfort. I go to my office wearing clothes according to my wish, only for meetings i prefer formals.;-)
    • The MOD Squad

    gohm Moderator

    Message Count:
    2,768
    Ratings Received:
    +33
    Engineering Discipline:
    Mechanical
    Speaking of air hostess, I always thought it was funny that they wear a uniform. Only 150 people around, if they are pushing the drink cart up & down the aisle etc... they're more than likely working. =)

    Discipline is vital however I feel that is best inforced via coaching for improved performance/reviews. I know you do to, It just can be hard if you are managing both employees' performance characteristics and other areas (like clothing police) all at the same time.

    kidakaka Maniac

    Message Count:
    814
    Ratings Received:
    +50
    Engineering Discipline:
    Computer Science
    Shucks .. I always pitied the stewards and air hostesses for putting up with such crappy (pardon my french) uniforms. Atleast some low cost airlines let them play around with the lenght of the skirt for individuality *thanks the policy* :)

    The firm should believe in the Theory Y, wherein all the employees stick to their roles and responsibilities. But that doesnt happen in real life, thats why firms like Infy, et al have dress codes like this ... ties on Monday, Tuesday!!

    MaRo Certified CEan

    Message Count:
    568
    Ratings Received:
    +4
    Engineering Discipline:
    Computer Science
    I don't prefer uniforms, just a small porch or card stuck on the top, this is very good and maintains individuality.
    • The MOD Squad

    ash Moderator

    Message Count:
    4,455
    Ratings Received:
    +34
    Engineering Discipline:
    Communications
    Ok, I guess its my fault for talking about "uniforms" in the first place ;) Obviously we dont wear uniforms in workplaces (i.e same colour, same style). Thats not what I'm talking about.

    When I said:
    and
    It was to reflect the role and perhaps culture of the organization of the place. I agree its not a sole method of instilling discipline, but.. whatever helps a little, right?

    However, I did say it would be nice to maintain some sort of.. er.. formality in the office. Business shirt, tie, business pants, work shoes.. not round neck t-shirts (except maybe the CE-Tee!), shorts and slippers (chappels?). Of course, as an engineer on the field, you'd wear something more rugged.

    crazysandy, I think nowadays military uniforms are designed to camouflage onself into the environment. Funny you mentioned about hospitality, though (hint: nurses) :p

    Anyhow, I hope we arent going off topic.. keep the discussion going!

    vivekji Certified CEan

    Message Count:
    32
    Ratings Received:
    +1
    There are few things which distinguishes people, one among them is the way they dress, We are not freaks to go on with cargos or some groovy outfits let us all be Engineers,
    let us all be professionals,
    • The MOD Squad

    Kaustubh Katdare The Good Admin

    Message Count:
    28,457
    Ratings Received:
    +2,860
    Engineering Discipline:
    Electrical
    Vivek, how would you connect being professional to the attire?

    integratdbrains CE - Value Adder

    Message Count:
    183
    Ratings Received:
    +2
    Engineering Discipline:
    Electronics
    I just wanted to discuss the peculiarity about both the places we are talking about i.e college and workplace. A dress code in college is always awaited by college going dudes.. all those days... Black and white,blue day,checks day... At that level ,its fun to celebrate a day ( for no occasion) with others...How did dressing everyone in same colour or pattern bring fun to us,how did that bring those lovely smiles on our faces?( I know most of you reading have already started smiling remembering those silly things you did as a collegiate! ) The days change and most of us either end up as entrepreneurs or as employees... Some things in life change but we never connect to what we do!
    Well but for the workplace much as we all say.. 'First impression is the last impression' I would not like anyone to judge my skills from my attire but at the same time I wouldn't want others to prolong the judgement for an Attire!

    vivekji Certified CEan

    Message Count:
    32
    Ratings Received:
    +1

    Freedom means responsibility my friend, the more the free you are the more likely you are likely to commit sin.....
    :p
    Even if you are dealing with public.
    Remember this

    "A Bomb is a Bomb, whereever it may be"-Netaji

    vivekji Certified CEan

    Message Count:
    32
    Ratings Received:
    +1
    Well to be realistic
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    People notice you first and then your dress,
    ...
    Soldiers don't get bored wearing uniforms, on the other hand they say it inspires them in to action

Share This Page