Nothing is good or bad-our thinking makes it so - Page 2

djnachi

Quote:

Originally Posted by no_atkt

as said something might be good according to ur logic but will be wrong acording to some1 else's logic ... you cant asy that what u think or some else thinks is the correct logic and it should followed by every1

it depends on what u define logic as and good as

as i said above ... for u jihadism might be illogical but ask the jihadis ... they are ready to die for it ... and mind u dont limit urself to just 1 segment .... if u had seen the news recently ther was a hostage situation where a guy held children as hostages demanding better facilities for the street children of his area ... is it logical, is it good, how would u categorize this incident

Hi there,

Speaking about the guy who held does innocent children hostages.,(i just had a small glimpse on that news so won't go in detail) his act could not be justified.

Going back to the root of this debate "What's good and what's wrong?" one can't say that what the man did is logically right or illogically wrong. Of course we all know that, to get highlighted or to make other people hear our voice, you either do the "BEST" or the "WORST".

So, I would say, YOUR GOOD SHOULD BE IN THE FAVOUR OF MANKIND!!

Regards,
Dj NAchi.

cshekhar

Quote:

Originally Posted by no_atkt

it depends on what u define logic as and good as

as i said above ... for u jihadism might be illogical but ask the jihadis ... they are ready to die for it ... and mind u dont limit urself to just 1 segment ....

heyy buddy....just ans this questn..

does that mean nothing is good or bad????

debachi.....errrrr.. dj nachi>>>
yes the post do sound more of a ans to the debate about "good or bad"....or one can say it can be best genralised the one in the faver of mankind or rather...whole of kinds...............

the point is good view and bad view for an object can be made bad or good or vice versa.. to a certain extent..depending upon a personal position...but definetly aftr certain limits r crossd its bad and its bad....or after certain limits its good for sure/....errrrrrrrr m sorry if u r getting confused..but hope is still there ...tht u wud undernd...

no_atkt · 02:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by djnachi

YOUR GOOD SHOULD BE IN THE FAVOUR OF MANKIND!!

that is your definition of good/right so acc. if anything goes against it is bad ... inother words your thinking made good to mankind "good" anything other than tht bad ..... i rest my case ... i think the debate has come to a conclusive end !!!

and btw the guy who hi-jacked the bus ... is now a national hero .... so again its the thinking of the people that made his act "good"

xheavenlyx

I can just say one thing. People are people, they just make bad choices because of the circumstances(war, stress etc) and conditioning(environment, ideology) they get. All of us have a sense of belonging, at the time we make a particular choice, our mental state at that moment can make it look 'good' or 'right', but later we may regret it.

So in the end, nothing is good or bad, its just the choices we make and how these choices effect people around us.

aashima

Quote:

Originally Posted by no_atkt

.... who decides that .... 10pm might b a deadline for u but for me it might b 2am ....

I think owing to difference in the ambience and situations, everyone has their own limits. 2 am could be very okay for someone, not for someone else. Definitions of good or bad is not same for everyone, but talking of the individual, they really are and then one drives life accordingly.

no_atkt

Quote:

Originally Posted by aashima

Definitions of good or bad is not same for everyone.

in other words .... nothing is good or bad

Quote:

Originally Posted by aashima

but talking of the individual, they really are and then one drives life accordingly.

in other words ... its an individual's thinking ...

add em both and you get:

nothing is good or bad, its our (your) thinking which makes it so

.... The End

aashima

Quote:

Originally Posted by no_atkt

in other words .... nothing is good or bad
in other words ... its an individual's thinking ...

add em both and you get:

nothing is good or bad, its our (your) thinking which makes it so

.... The End

Well in discussions its always advisable to go with the majority. If nothing actually is good or bad, then Osama Bin Laden should be completely justified for every deed of his. Along with him, all the people in the same league and race. Say what??

miteshmanani

In Max Payne's words...

"Its all a matter of perspective, tied to time and place,"... furthur goes.. "Love and Friendship, Life and Death"

Osama bin Laden has committed a crime at a whole lot of Higher Level and caused many deaths.

There is a vast difference between "Good-Bad" and "Crime causing deaths."

With Regards,
Mitesh Manani
http://getpass.netfirms.com

no_atkt

Quote:

Originally Posted by aashima

Say what??

go thruogh the posts iv said this in the initail posts itself ... a terrorsit for 1 land is a freedom fighter for another land ... and thats what max payne's perspective talks about ... for osama and his followers what they do is justified (their thinking about good) but for us what they do is not justified (our thinking about bad) .... hence i again say Nothing is good or Bad .... its ouyr thinking which makes it so

aashima

Quote:

Originally Posted by no_atkt

go thruogh the posts iv said this in the initail posts itself ... a terrorsit for 1 land is a freedom fighter for another land ... and thats what max payne's perspective talks about ... for osama and his followers what they do is justified (their thinking about good) but for us what they do is not justified (our thinking about bad) .... hence i again say Nothing is good or Bad .... its ouyr thinking which makes it so

Correct me if I am wrong, Osama is not one of those who are fighting for a noble cause. Their prime and the only reason is to spread terror. Thanks to Mr. Laden that Afghanistan has been completely destroyed by USA , as was expected. And also, are all the Indian mafias as in Dawood, Abu Salem etc are fighting for India? Well I don't see any noble rather a justified reason for them to be seated in a chair they hold right now.