Does "Ahimsa" work in modern times?

The_Big_K

The question is pretty straightforward. We need world peace. Do you think the solution lies in Ahimsa?

Why?

ash

You mean, being a sort of pacifist?

mad_scientist

i believe a modified concept of ahimsa might work allright..one where you tolerate things to make sure the situation does not get out of hand, but at the same time have the capability to stop a situation from getting out of hand..

The_Big_K

Quote:

Originally Posted by ash

You mean, being a sort of pacifist?

Sort of.

Quote:

Originally Posted by mad_scientist

i believe a modified concept of ahimsa might work allright..one where you tolerate things to make sure the situation does not get out of hand, but at the same time have the capability to stop a situation from getting out of hand..

Could you please elaborate it, possible with an example?

mad_scientist

you're being teased by a dude..you don't want to fight him, so you ignore him. But if he threatens you with a knife, you tackle him and take his knife away..

ash

What if you're unable to tackle him properly and he manages to knife you?

Does ignoring always work? Perhaps some nice talk could work before physical action is needed.

The_Big_K

What I'm trying to figure out is whether there's workaround available in the principles of Ahimsa.

If I get attacked, I'd rather opt for self defense - which may involve counter attack. Ash's point is valid.

Or is there something we are failing to understand about Ahimsa? Anyone?

mad_scientist

yes, of course i agree. before tackling, you should exhaust all your civil options, talking sense, maybe seeking intervention from a third party, but when all else fails you have to protect your existence by any means..

and when i say make sure you have the capability to prevent a situation from getting out of hand i mean it (consider you're a rugby player

for the example)

ash

Biggie, can you describe in detail the principles of Ahimsa if you dont mind?

The_Big_K

Quote:

Originally Posted by ash

Biggie, can you describe in detail the principles of Ahimsa if you dont mind?

I don't know. "Principles of Ahimsa" just popped up in my mind out of nowhere. Sorry.